Carnelian Ring

Feb 13
2009

Carnelian+Ring
Engagement ring ideas: Metal band set with stone(s) versus a band made of just the stone.Which is better&why?

I like the idea of a faceted carnelian ring for my engagement band best, but am wondering whether it'd be more practical to just get a metal band with a carnelian [or perhaps sapphire or emerald] in it.

Any hints/tips? Pros/cons of each? No budget set yet but partner and I are both students right now so cheapish would be best.

Many thanks

You would want to look into the strength and durability of carnelian and see if it's a good choice in those arenas.

I think it would be perfectly comfortable as a band or as a stone in a band.

Obviously, the stone in the metal band will give you more of an engagement ring look, but it's up to you.

I would suggest you try on lots of rings, even buy cheaper versions and wear them around and see how they feel. Consider your lifestyle and take into account how long you expect to wear these rings, will you upgrade in 5 years or do you expect to die in these rings or to be able to pass them down through your family? And try not to go too crazy and spend months debating with yourself over what you actually want (like me!).

If you're open to other ideas, tungsten is becoming a very popular metal for men's bands, and is quite cheap. For yourself, titanium is very cheap and there are more women's designs now than ever. Of course, there's gold, 10k or 14k will be your more affordable options. If you like platinum, palladium is its cheaper sister metal. I would avoid sterling silver which is a little too cheap for wedding jewelry and should be left to costume jewelry. Sterling silver might be fine if you're willing to upgrade after a short period.

As far as a stone, sapphires are a great choice, this includes rubies. They're very hard and can handle daily wear. Emerald isn't such a great choice as it is softer and more susceptible to damage. You could always get another stone in an emerald colour, however. I love moissanite and it's what I've chosen, more beautiful than a diamond and at a fraction of the price. If you're open to CZ make note there are different grades from A-AAAAA. Anything over AAA is excellent quality and will hopefully last your lifetime, though CZ is prone to clouding over time. A and AA CZ are very inexpensive, but may need to be traded out in a year or two. Maybe you might want to get a cheap CZ to start and then just upgrade the stone to whatever when you're in a better financial position. You might be interested in checking out the various gemstones, including carnelian, here: http://www.gemselect.com/group/gemselect.php?x_ByType=on

And a better choice might be waiting until you're done school and can afford a great ring to start with.

Good Luck!

Glow by Sheila Fajl Fresh Garden Red Carnelian Ring

eBay Logo  

ISRAEL STERLING SILVER CARNELIAN SAW TOOTH SETTING FLORAL FILIGREE DESIGN RING


ISRAEL STERLING SILVER CARNELIAN SAW TOOTH SETTING FLORAL FILIGREE DESIGN RING


$6.99


Antique 1900 Arts & Crafts Natural Carnelian Solid 835 European Silver Mens Ring


Antique 1900 Arts & Crafts Natural Carnelian Solid 835 European Silver Mens Ring


$50.00


Vintage Estate Sterling Silver & Carnelian Ring


Vintage Estate Sterling Silver & Carnelian Ring


$21.95


Vintage Estate Carnelian 10k Gold Cocktail Ring Fine Statement Heirloom Jewelry


Vintage Estate Carnelian 10k Gold Cocktail Ring Fine Statement Heirloom Jewelry


$595.00


Huge Chunky Vintage Polished Banded Agate/Carnelian  Band Ring size 7 1/4


Huge Chunky Vintage Polished Banded Agate/Carnelian Band Ring size 7 1/4


$46.99


BEAUTIFUL VICTORIAN NATURAL CARNELIAN & MARCASITE STERLING SILVER RING NR


BEAUTIFUL VICTORIAN NATURAL CARNELIAN & MARCASITE STERLING SILVER RING NR


$20.00


VINTAGE STERLING SILVER 925 RING W/CARNELIAN COLOR ALMOND/EYE SHAPE STONE 4.5 GR


VINTAGE STERLING SILVER 925 RING W/CARNELIAN COLOR ALMOND/EYE SHAPE STONE 4.5 GR


$9.99


ANTIQUE VICTORIAN LG STERLING FILIGREE CARNELIAN STONE RING DESIGNER C.P.


ANTIQUE VICTORIAN LG STERLING FILIGREE CARNELIAN STONE RING DESIGNER C.P.


$9.99


VINTAGE CARNELIAN RING STERLING SIZE 5 FABULOUS DESIGN MUSTIC!!


VINTAGE CARNELIAN RING STERLING SIZE 5 FABULOUS DESIGN MUSTIC!!


$55.00


Art deco Sterling Carnelian Marcasite Ring


Art deco Sterling Carnelian Marcasite Ring


$9.99


Vintage Estate Carnelian Jade 14k Gold Cocktail Ring Band Fine Heirloom Jewelry


Vintage Estate Carnelian Jade 14k Gold Cocktail Ring Band Fine Heirloom Jewelry


$399.00


VINTAGE CARVED CARNELIAN RING STAMPED 925  SIZE 6 1/2 MUSTIC!!!!


VINTAGE CARVED CARNELIAN RING STAMPED 925 SIZE 6 1/2 MUSTIC!!!!


$55.00


Carnelian & Garnet Sterling Silver 30.8g Ladies Necklace & Ring Jewelry CUTE!


Carnelian & Garnet Sterling Silver 30.8g Ladies Necklace & Ring Jewelry CUTE!


$1.25


ANTIQUE ART DECO CARNELIAN BANDED SCOTTISH AGATE STERLING RING STUNNING!


ANTIQUE ART DECO CARNELIAN BANDED SCOTTISH AGATE STERLING RING STUNNING!


$395.00


NANA'S Vintage ORNATE Sterling Silver Carnelian High Domed Ring Size: 11


NANA'S Vintage ORNATE Sterling Silver Carnelian High Domed Ring Size: 11


$62.09


ANTIQUE ART DECO CARNELIAN RING 14K WHITE GOLD


ANTIQUE ART DECO CARNELIAN RING 14K WHITE GOLD


$159.20


ANTIQUE 1920'S ART DECO 14K CARNELIAN ROCK CRYSTAL RING SIZE 6.5.


ANTIQUE 1920'S ART DECO 14K CARNELIAN ROCK CRYSTAL RING SIZE 6.5.


$254.32


Vintage India Ethnic CARNELIAN Ring Silver Plate Boho Sz 7.5 Large Stone Natural


Vintage India Ethnic CARNELIAN Ring Silver Plate Boho Sz 7.5 Large Stone Natural


$39.95


ANTIQUE ART DECO CAMEO RING 10K YELLOW GOLD CARNELIAN


ANTIQUE ART DECO CAMEO RING 10K YELLOW GOLD CARNELIAN


$159.20


Estate 14K Gold & Carnelian Chinese Dragon Ring SIze 7


Estate 14K Gold & Carnelian Chinese Dragon Ring SIze 7


$389.99


Antique Victorian 8ct Natural Carnelian Solitaire 10k Yellow Gold Ring 2.8g


Antique Victorian 8ct Natural Carnelian Solitaire 10k Yellow Gold Ring 2.8g


$20.50


VINTAGE STERLING SILVER RING SOUTHWEST MOTIF turquoise & carnelian stones


VINTAGE STERLING SILVER RING SOUTHWEST MOTIF turquoise & carnelian stones


$16.95


Vintage Art Deco sterling marcasite carnelian ring – large oval


Vintage Art Deco sterling marcasite carnelian ring – large oval


$24.85


LARGE 10G MAN'S VINTAGE STERLING SILVER CARNELIAN BANDED AGATE RING AA15


LARGE 10G MAN'S VINTAGE STERLING SILVER CARNELIAN BANDED AGATE RING AA15


$9.49


VINTAGE 14K Yellow Gold Carved Carnelian Cameo Ring size 10-10¼


VINTAGE 14K Yellow Gold Carved Carnelian Cameo Ring size 10-10¼


$750.00


VINTAGE 14K Yellow Gold Large Carved Carnelian Intaglio Ring size 10¼


VINTAGE 14K Yellow Gold Large Carved Carnelian Intaglio Ring size 10¼


$850.00


STERLING SILVER 925 RING SIZE 9.75 LARGE OVAL RED CARNELIAN 10.3 GRAMS EXCELLENT


STERLING SILVER 925 RING SIZE 9.75 LARGE OVAL RED CARNELIAN 10.3 GRAMS EXCELLENT


$16.99


Vintage Ring Carnelian Cab Goldtone Size 5.5 USA Estate 100s in Store rr


Vintage Ring Carnelian Cab Goldtone Size 5.5 USA Estate 100s in Store rr


$28.00


Gogeous Sterling Silver 925 Bezel Set Carnelian Cocktail Dinner Ring 8.9 gr.


Gogeous Sterling Silver 925 Bezel Set Carnelian Cocktail Dinner Ring 8.9 gr.


$45.00


Wonderful Vintage Carved Carnelian and Filigree Sterling Ring Deco Edwardian


Wonderful Vintage Carved Carnelian and Filigree Sterling Ring Deco Edwardian


$39.99


STERLING SILVER CARNELIAN SAWTOOTH BEADED FLUTED DETAILING BRAIDED TRIM RING


STERLING SILVER CARNELIAN SAWTOOTH BEADED FLUTED DETAILING BRAIDED TRIM RING


$9.99


STERLING SILVER CARNELIAN FILIGREE BRAIDED TRIM DRAGONFLY CONCAVE PEDESTAL RING


STERLING SILVER CARNELIAN FILIGREE BRAIDED TRIM DRAGONFLY CONCAVE PEDESTAL RING


$12.99


VINTAGE 925 SILVER CARNELIAN RING-ABSTRACT MODERNIST DESIGN- UNSIGNED DESIGNER


VINTAGE 925 SILVER CARNELIAN RING-ABSTRACT MODERNIST DESIGN- UNSIGNED DESIGNER


$25.00


Vintage Sterling MARCASITE CARNELIAN Inlay Art Deco Style RING~SZ 8,fjt


Vintage Sterling MARCASITE CARNELIAN Inlay Art Deco Style RING~SZ 8,fjt


$22.00


Lovely 10K YG ring with Carnelian Cabochon


Lovely 10K YG ring with Carnelian Cabochon


$89.00


Vintage Carnelian Sterling Silver Ring


Vintage Carnelian Sterling Silver Ring


$4.95


NICE DAINTY ESTATE STERLING SILVER & CARNELIAN BAND RING SZ SIZE 9


NICE DAINTY ESTATE STERLING SILVER & CARNELIAN BAND RING SZ SIZE 9


$54.99


50s MID CENTURY MODERN AMERICAN MODERNIST MOD KAY WHITE STERLING CARNELIAN? RING


50s MID CENTURY MODERN AMERICAN MODERNIST MOD KAY WHITE STERLING CARNELIAN? RING


$85.00


Vintage Sterling Silver Carnelian Agate Cabochon Scarab Beetle Ring Egyptian 925


Vintage Sterling Silver Carnelian Agate Cabochon Scarab Beetle Ring Egyptian 925


$24.95


Hatpin with a plain carnelian seal suitable for engraving & mounting as a ring


Hatpin with a plain carnelian seal suitable for engraving & mounting as a ring


$7.89


Sterling Silver PAIR 13.00X18.00 MM Genuine Carnelian, Mother Of Pearl & Onyx Cuff Links


Sterling Silver PAIR 13.00X18.00 MM Genuine Carnelian, Mother Of Pearl & Onyx Cuff Links


$149.71


Genuine Carnelian, Mother Of Pearl & Onyx Cuff Links Quality: Sterling Silver Size: PAIR 13.00X18.00 MM Total Carat Weight: 0.0000 Primary Metal Composition: Sterling SilverWeight: 7.65 GMThis product comes with a FREE Gift Box...

ADA Collection Carnelian Belt


ADA Collection Carnelian Belt



Soft gathered leather wrap embellished with bronze stud detailing and hidden velcro for adjustable fit....


Turkmen Jewelry: Silver Ornaments from the Marshall and Marilyn R. Wolf Collection (Metropolitan Museum of Art)


Turkmen Jewelry: Silver Ornaments from the Marshall and Marilyn R. Wolf Collection (Metropolitan Museum of Art)


$37.80


The Turkmen people of Central Asia and Iran are revered for their carpets and textiles. Less well known, but equally stunning, is the extraordinary silver jewelry created by Turkmen tribal craftsmen and urban silversmiths throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries. This catalogue presents nearly two hundred pieces in glorious detail, ranging from crowns and headdresses to armbands and rings, and...

Carnelian Ring


Carnelian Ring


$75


The carnelian ring radiates with beauty. The glowing red carnelian is set with four leaf shaped prongs of sterling silver. The beaded and cable details add an ornate touch to this stunning ring.

Carnelian Crown of Light Ring


Carnelian Crown of Light Ring


$135


There is a regal essence inherent in this Crown of Light ring. Featured here in Carnelian, a rich brownish-red stone is cut in round faceted fashion and nestled into a silver base fashioned to resemble a crown. Ring diameter 1 inch.

Turquoise and Persian Carnelian Double Date Ring


Turquoise and Persian Carnelian Double Date Ring


$165


This turquoise and Persian carnelian double date ring is truly stunning. The turquoise stone is shaped like a square and gorgeously designed. On the other end of the 18k gold vermeil ring is the Persian carnelian stone that also stands out. The ring is adjustable from sizes 6 to 10.

6mm wide Carnelian Band Gemstone Ring


6mm wide Carnelian Band Gemstone Ring


$7.99


This band is made from stone and it is Fragile. Please Buy only if you think you will be able to handle with care. Carnelian Gemstone Band. Gorgeous and Lovely. Band has a smooth and shiny finish. You will love it. Ring will be shipped in a Free gift box making it easy for you to surprise your special someone. Thank you for shopping at Gem Avenue! Adjustable: No Size/Dimensions: 6.5 Material: Jade

Dyed Carnelian Gemstone Agate 6mm wide Faceted Band Ring


Dyed Carnelian Gemstone Agate 6mm wide Faceted Band Ring


$7.99


This band is made from stone and it is Fragile. Please Buy only if you think you will be able to handle with care.Faceted Dyed Carnelian Gemstone Agate Band. Gorgeous and Lovely. Carnelian Color is very pleasing. Please visit our store for different sizes. Color of the band varies from ring to ring as they come from different stones with varying depths. Some might be lighter and some darker. Ring will be shipped in a Free gift box making it easy for you to surprise your special someone. Thank you for shopping at Gem Avenue! Adjustable: No Size/Dimensions: 8.5 Material: Jade

Carnelian Bracelet


Carnelian Bracelet


$180


Get noticed in the bright and bold hues of the carnelian bracelet. The faceted carnelian beads are accented by a brushed gold vermeil bead for added texture.This naturally beautiful bracelet fastens with a gold vermeil toggle clasp.

Evelyn Knight Carnelian Earrings


Evelyn Knight Carnelian Earrings


$56


Evelyn Knight Carnelian Earrings are fantastic. The carnelian stone embellishments add the perfect dash of glamour and charm.

Genuine Elegante (TM) Product. 16+2Extension Necklace With Carnelian, Apatite, Aquamarine And Cultured Freshwater Pearls. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.


Genuine Elegante (TM) Product. 16+2Extension Necklace With Carnelian, Apatite, Aquamarine And Cultured Freshwater Pearls. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.


$59.95


Genuine Elegante (TM) Product. 16"+2"Extension Necklace With Carnelian, Apatite, Aquamarine And Cultured Freshwater Pearls. 16" + 2" Extension Sterling Silver 1Mm Chain Necklace With 20Mm X 10Mm Faceted Carnelian, 8.5Mm Cultured Freshwater Pearl, Appatite Chips And Mother Of Pearl Drop From A 21.5Mm Ring. Necklace Has A Lobster Clasp Closure .925 Sterling Silver. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed. Material: Sterling-silver Condition: New
Be Sociable, Share!

Comments are closed.